Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Legal Research

This guide will provide basic legal information that can be found in the NMSU Library and elsewhere on the internet.

Shepardizing a Case

N.B. Shepard's is a way to determine changes in law since its inception. To "shepardize" a legal case means to trace its history and note various changes. Shepardizing is especially important for lawyers when citing cases that may have subsequently been overturned or revised in some way. For more details on Shepard's, see this helpful Lexis-Nexis help sheet


1. First Steps in Shepardizing a Case
Go to Advanced Search-->
Legal-->Cases-->United States Cases

To narrow, search by case name or citation. In this example, I searched by citation


2. Look at the Treatment Levels
Note the different treatment levels, outlined in PURPLE below. The yellow triangle indicates caution, showing that parts of this case law have been questioned or that different interpretations in court decisions prevail. 


3. Shepardize the Headnotes
You can also Shepardize the Headnotes. These describe the different aspects of the law. In the first example, Freedom of Speech, Fighting Words is shepardized with two cautionary notes and 8 positive ones. 


4. Display a Shepard's Map

You can view the relationships between the items in the Appellate History and display a downloadable chart for saving and printing.

Click on the Subsequent Appellate History link. 


To show a chart, click on the Map icon on the far right. (The display below shows a title view of appellate history for this particular case). 


Below you see a display of the case's appellate history. In this example, the case bounced back and forth between many, many different appellate courts.